Underproofed or Overproofed?

Toast

Newbie sourdough-er here.

Without giving too much info, does this baked loaf look underproofed or overproofed to you?

Thanks for your help!

Looks under too me as well. Poke it and make sure its size has increased to your liking (i prefer 1.5 x better than double) as it comes our of the fridge. 

Yeah, your starter might be a problem, but also the flour, direct contact of salt and starter and even too much chlorine or minerals in your water. 

Agreed on under proofed.  After seeing the times you listed I'd say almost 100%.  You'd need the most powerful starter in the world to over proof in 4 hours.