To prevent unsightly pinhole crumbs caused by excessive hydration of whole wheat flour, before I bake, I test the flour's absorption capacity by autolyzing it under different hydration levels and observing its gluten development. The hydration at which the dough starts to slack/tear is the bottom line for me to stop adding water to the dough.
Alternatively, if my dough contains more than whole wheat flour, I can still judge the maximum hydration of the dough during the mixing process without pre-testing (such as how I do it here).
At the pre-dough stage, I use just enough water to form a dough that I can knead/mix easily later on.
At the mixing stage, I mix the pre-dough, to further develop/strengthen its gluten to ~ medium+ development before adding more water. I continue to mix and add more water gradually to maximize the dough's hydration. I take care not to over-mix since the whole wheat dough is fragile.
Also, I found that using CLAS in the whole-wheat dough can significantly improve its quality. In addition to imparting superb flavors to the whole-wheat bread, CLAS also tenderizes its crumb, making it supple like white bread, even if it's a lean dough with no fat, dairy, sugar, or vital wheat gluten (such as this and this).
I apply similar principles when developing gluten for "white" dough.
So, when I mix the dough, it looks like this:
- Add flour to the mixer
- Start the mixer
- Gradually add water until a dough is formed
- Make a note of how much water has been added so far for future reference
- (At this point, you may autolyze the dough)
- Gradually add more water until the mixer can easily knead the dough.
- Stop adding water
- Continue mixing the dough to develop gluten until the dough feels strong
- Add salt and yeast, and sugar, if using, and continue to mix to incorporate
- Add fat, if using, and continue mixing until incorporated
- Gradually mix in more water until the dough is about to "collapse".
- Yippee's Blog
- Log in or register to post comments
This is just opposite to what I was doing! (wet ingred on the bottom and flour on top).
The clas is thawing now!