When to stop kneading

Profile picture for user Sour_Baker

Does it depend on the type of bread?

 When I first started learning about bread you knead until you pass the window test. Now I find out you should not be doing that for sourdough at all.

 Is that for all sourdough, whether enriched, lean, high hydration?

It depends on whether you will be doing a long, slow bulk fermentation or not.  If you are going to ferment for 6,8,10+ hours, time will do most of the work - a few stretch and fold sessions early in the bulk ferment will most likely be all you need.  A windowpane test wouldn't be needed at all.

If you are aiming to be done with bulk fermenting in a few hours, there won't be time for this process to work out fully, so you might need to help it by doing more kneading/stretching near the beginning.

Either way, things will go better (and be easier) if you give the dough a rest after initial mixing.  Half and hour seems to be a good length, but at least 15 minutes.  This rest lets the flour hydrate and start developing the gluten.  Afterwards it will be much easier to complete kneading.