Atta sandwich loaf

Toast

So here goes, my first entry.  I have been lurking around these parts for a while, gathering information and experimenting and this is the result: a 100% wholemeal sandwich loaf, using atta flour.

This project began around one year ago after I was diagnosed with Type 2 Diabetes and had to overhaul both my diet and lifestyle.  Out went the white bread sandwich for breakfast every morning, and the hunt was on for a replacement.  Living in Francophone West Africa, where it is super-easy to get white baguettes etc., finding a decent wholemeal loaf was very difficult virtually impossible.  That left me with only one solution: to start making my own.

After some searching on the internet, the received wisdom seemed to be that bread made with 100% wholemeal flour was, by definition, unpalatably dense; due to both the lower levels of gluten in brown flour and the propensity of the bran's sharp edges to slice through what little gluten there was.  I also recalled from years ago when my mum used to bake bread when I was young that she used a 2:1 brown to white mix.  Faced with the prospect of finding a solution that would last me the rest of my life, I resolved to find a recipe that used 100% wholemeal flour and was nice to eat.  Being married to a half-Indian lady, I had also been introduced to atta flour.  I was keen to try this in bread since it is (a) 100% wholemeal and (b) smoother than Western-style brown flour.

After some time, it became apparent that there was no one recipe out there which could satisfy all of my requirements, so I started experimenting and combining the best parts of various other recipes which I had found.  The following recipe is the result of those experiments.  Any tips from those more experienced than myself would be greatly appreciated.

 

100% Wholemeal Brown Bread (Atta Flour) 

Ingredients

  • 6 cups Atta Flour
  • 2 cups, 2 Tablespoons Water
  • 1/4 cup Plain Yoghurt
  • 1/4 cup Olive Oil
  • 2 tablespoons Brown Sugar
  • 2 teaspoons Instant Yeast
  • 2 teaspoons Salt
  • 2 teaspoons Herbs (optional)
  • A little Milk

  

Method

  1. Take two large bowls.  In Bowl 1 (Autolyse), add 4 cups of flour and 1 cup of water and mix well.  This should result in the flour forming into small clumps.  In Bowl 2 (Poolish), add 2 cups of flour, 2 teaspoons of yeast, 1 cup of water and 1/4 cup of yoghurt and mix well.  This should result in a smooth, soft, wet dough.
  2. Cover both bowls with a tea towel and leave for one hour.  After this time, you should be able to see the yeast working; the dough in Bowl 2 has expanded and the surface is pock-marked by small bubbles.
  3. Add the salt, sugar and olive oil (and herbs, if using) into Bowl 1 and mix well enough to ensure that the salt is well spread throughout the mixture.
  4. Combine the two bowls into one and mix until the dough forms a cohesive whole.  There will still be small hard lumps at this stage.
  5. Tip the dough out onto an oiled work surface and knead well until all of the small lumps have been absorbed and you have a homogenous dough.
  6. Slowly add around 2 tablespoons of water as you kneed, and more oil if you prefer, so that the dough becomes slightly sticky.
  7. Continue to kneed for another 10-15 minutes; the dough should be soft, smooth and elastic.  The dough will stick to the work surface if left to sit, but not when kept moving.
  8. Place the dough in a bowl, lightly brush the top with water, cover with a tea towel and leave in a warm place for around one hour.
  9. Deflate the dough and allow it to continue fermenting for 30 minutes more.
  10. Turn the dough out onto the work surface and cut into two pieces.  Shape into loaves and place into greased tins.
  11. Cover and leave in a warm place for around 45 minutes; until the loaves rise to the tops of the tins.
  12. Lightly brush the tops of the loaves with a little milk.  Bake for 10 minutes at 220°C, then reduce to 200°C for a further 20 minutes.
  13. When the loaves are fully baked (sound hollow when tapped), remove from the oven.  Allow them to cool in the tins for around 10 minutes before turning them out onto a cooling rack.

 

Working time:   45 minutes

Waiting time:    3 hours 15 minutes

Cooking time:   30 minutes                   

Total:               4.5 hours

  

Express Method

To be used when short of time.  I would use this if I were baking in the evening, once the kids were in bed and I needed bread for breakfast the next morning.  The results are satisfactory to put bread on the table, but not fantastic.

 Reduce Steps 2 & 11 to 30 minutes, Step 7 to 10 minutes and Step 8 to 40 minutes.  Eliminate Step 9.  Total: 2.5 hours

Hi Lechem,  thanks for the tips.  I would indeed wish not to add sugar, but I understood that this was necessary to feed the yeast.  Can I skip this entirely?

Given that my bread making, and indeed my entire life just now, is scheduled around two young kids, perhaps I can try leaving the poolish overnight.

My main aim in this was to have a reliable, practical recipe, which after several repeats of the exact same process, I feel I've achieved.  Now to start experimenting again!

But the yeast needs no added sugar. You can skip that out. It can feed on the sugars in the flour.

I recommend you to find a dedicated poolish recipe and just use atta flour instead to the hydration you prefer.

Another option to use within a recipe is a tangzhong. Take 5% of the flour + 5x it's weight from the total water. Mix in a pan and gently heat on a low flame. In a few minutes it'll gel. Once it gets streaky and gel like then remove from the flame, transfer the tangzhong and cool. Add this too the recipe remembering you've used part of the flour and water so just make-up the dough with the remainder.

As for spice how about a bit of cinnamon? Will help control the sugars. Or other spices that will be beneficial. Important when using cinnamon is to know the correct amount when using in this way. For bread and helping with diabetes. A little goes a long way. But I'm sure you know about that.

Overdoing it can have side effects due to a chemical in cinnamon. Try and also find true cinnamon (zeylancium, Ceylon Cinnamon) instead of Cassia (Chinese cinnamon) as this has far less of that chemical.

I also read that wholemeal flour is not suitable for tangzhong - have you had any success with this?

Spice-wise I've used cumin a couple of times and really like that.  My brain associates cinnamon with sweet baking, so I might need to overcome a psychological hurdle and try that.

That one still looks like white bread. Yes, you can skip the sugar and I agree with all of Lechem's suggestions. I always did straight doughs fermented overnight and even 4 days and the flavour is the same when you use a pre-ferment if not better and a lot easier.

has to be tasty.  Some folks add some sugar to the mix, not for the yeast, but to compensate for any bitter flavor in the wheat bran.  Here in the states the Atta we get from India is not wholemeal.  It is milled to a white patent flour a=with the germ and bran removed and then some of the ban is added back into the flour creating some kind iof whole wheat flour but the all of the germ is removed so the flour doesn't spoil and go rancid so fast.