The Fresh Loaf

A Community of Amateur Bakers and Artisan Bread Enthusiasts.

Howdy from New Hampshire

Unix Commando's picture
Unix Commando

Howdy from New Hampshire

Greetings from New Hampshire,

    Hi, my name is Bob, I'm a native of New Hampshire, the best state in the union.  I'm a hit or miss bread baker who is looking to learn how to get more consistent results with my bread.  

    When I was a child my grandmother always made home made bread, I remember she called it her no knead milk bread.  I do remember her kneading it and my dad does as well, but I'm thinking that she didn't knead it for a long time.  None of us had the mind to really learn from gram how she made her bread, so I don't have the exact recipe she used.  My cousin lived with gram for a couple of years and while he didn't make a great examination of her recipe he was able to give my sister what he remembered about it.  My sister makes a bread that has some of the characteristics I remember in gram's bread but is missing others and I've been trying, through trial and error, to improve upon it.

    Gram's bread wasn't what I would call a sandwich bread, it didn't have that soft spongy texture you see with sandwich bread and was really poor as a sandwich bread, but was fantastic for toast and a nice bread to butter with a meal.  The crumb was a little more open than a sandwich bread, but not as great as a brioche or other artisan bread.  When toasted the crumb had a nice crunch without being too soft or chewy.  The bread had a yeasty smell and flavor which was enhanced with butter.

    My sisters version has a similar smell and flavor to gram's but her bread has a really dense crumb with small bubbles and never gets that mushroom shaped cross section that you see in a sandwich bread.

    I'm hoping that this forum can help me dial in what's missing.  I've been able to get closer to grams bread than my sister, but I haven't been able to do so consistently so I'm hear to learn from you all how to identify my mistakes and correct them.

Cheers

-Bob

Phazm's picture
Phazm

This forum won't make the ingredients the same - and there lies the difference. Make what you like and use. Enjoy! 

tpassin's picture
tpassin

how to identify my mistakes and correct them.

You aren't making mistakes.  You just haven't hit on the right combination of ingredients and process to recreate something you remember from a long time ago  (and may not be remembering with full fidelity, anyway).

The next step if you want help, is to say what it is your are making (i.e., the recipe) and your process.  Also, I don't really grasp what your target is and where your bread is falling short.  So please say some more about that.

Softness in a sandwich bread usually comes from some combination of the hydration and the enhancements - milk, eggs, butter, and so forth. You can decrease the softness by reducing the enhancements, and you can open up the crumb with a higher hydration or longer fermentation time.

TomP

pmccool's picture
pmccool

That will at least provide a point to begin from.  And people can suggest modifications that would move the bread closer to what you remember. 

Paul