The Fresh Loaf

A Community of Amateur Bakers and Artisan Bread Enthusiasts.

Dough not setting up

theoriginalmirj's picture
theoriginalmirj

Dough not setting up

Hi all,

 I found a recipe off the internet, probably just like a whole host of others, and have used it twice before with okay results.  Today, it is not working...that said, I did change it up a bit, so thought I would do the early stages differently, and being a rookie, I probably made a rookie mistake.

Here is what I have so far.  The starter is a 100% hydration dark rye flour. This next bit was part of the recipe. I used 20 g of my starter, 90 g H2O and 90 g flour. I used unbleached AP for this, and I did a preferment for 24 hours.

The recipe calls for 200g of preferment, 800 g of flour, (again, I used unbleached AP), 800 g of H2O, and 20 g of salt.

Where I departed from the recipe is here. I autolysed the flour and water for 24 hours, then added the salt and preferment.

Since putting it all together, it has not set up at all.  I have run through all the stages to where I am letting it sit in the couche for the next 2 - 3 hours.  When I went to form it and cut it to make my loaves, the dough was still very wet, sticky and unincorporated.  I should say I live in Canada and today is a coolish 12 C.

Where did I go wrong? 

 

MiRJ 

 

Amara's picture
Amara

A 100% hydration dough is pretty unforgiving for rookies. A 24 hour autolyse may have lead to too much enzymatic activity in the flour alongside the "pre-ferment" (typically called a levain when referring to sourdough) and decreased dough stability. Or it could have simply been a more humid day, less absorbent batch of flour since the last time you made it, and so on. The easiest way in my experience to "guarantee" good structure in such a high hydration loaf is to start with about 80% of the water, let it rest, check consistency, work in 5% more, let it rest, check consistency, etc etc until you've given the loaf all it is willing to take, or used all of the water you desire to.

theoriginalmirj's picture
theoriginalmirj

Hi Amara,

I am going to go with the decreased stabilty, and probably not do the autolyse next time.  Plus, I will try your suggestion of the staged hydration of the dough.  Thanks!

I am still going to bake the loaves and see how they turn out.